Some sort of self portrait...

[Paul.S.]

I like the composition a great deal and the idea of the color occuring only in the chrome. Just my opinion mind you, but the reflection of the red body panels of the car throws me off, have you tried if not completely then partial desaturating the color?..

cheers...

P.

[Iamcndn]

is that a mini cooper...? hehe

Good abstract s.p.!

[Seb]

Hello guys,

Here are two new versions as promised.

I have decided to blur the edge betwen the mirror and the background with the water drop tool in order to hide its perfectible nature. While I don't know if it was the best thing to do or not, I must say that I rather like the result.

Seb

[readingr]

Excellent I like the clarity of the reflections in the mirror. The one question I have is - are the cars in the reflections on ramps? I would have prefered them to be removed for the shot.

[Seb]

Excellent I like the clarity of the reflections in the mirror. The one question I have is - are the cars in the reflections on ramps? I would have prefered them to be removed for the shot.

Thanks for commenting again. The cars you are reffering at do are a bunch of BMW's 3 series on ramps. I am not sure that I would like to have a part of the mirror cropped out but I do realise that the backdrop is perfectible.

regards

Seb

[gahspidy]

Seb,
Great job cropping and ps. Both of these I find appealing but was rather impressed immediately with the full frame mirror image. Yes, it could have been more if there was a better scene going on behind you, but as this stands with the clouds and the white line in the parking lot underlining you and just the interesting wide angle effect the mirror brings to us is good enough. I feel this is a fine self portrait full of creativity and appeal.

[Seb]

Seb,
Great job cropping and ps. Both of these I find appealing but was rather impressed immediately with the full frame mirror image. Yes, it could have been more if there was a better scene going on behind you, but as this stands with the clouds and the white line in the parking lot underlining you and just the interesting wide angle effect the mirror brings to us is good enough. I feel this is a fine self portrait full of creativity and appeal.

Hello Gary,

Thanks for the kind words. I am glad to know that these works for you.

Seb

[CarbonTerry]

My thoughts are that a self portrait should give some insight to the person that is the photographer.

[Seb]

My thoughts are that a self portrait should give some insight to the person that is the photographer.

Hello CarbonTerry,

I am sorry but I am not sure that I understand what you mean here. Could you further explain your thoughts?

regards

Seb

[CarbonTerry]

Sure....
Your pix are merely shots of your reflection in shiny car parts. They convey nothing to the viewer about who/what you are. The best portraits let the viewer into the soul of the subject. For example, the portrait of Winston Churchill by Joseuf Karsch (do a Google). This lets you know that you don't want to screw with this guy.
Rarely is a self portrait sucessful....
This is my very first attempt circa 1972

[gahspidy]

CarbonTerry,
I would agree with you on those points about self-Portraits, but I think the use of the term here is to be taken lightly. . just a sort of reference to the fact that the photographer is evident inthe shot. I have included my self in a number of my shots merely as a character to create a scene, but would not consider them to be self portraits. But I think there are many different types of self portraits, some of which fall into a more creative category, such as this and those that are more straight forward with the sole intent on giving the viewer the subject in his/her entirety. This "self Portrait" to me is more about the composition and creativity than it is about letting me know who the photographer is.
Just my take on all this. . .

[Seb]

Sure....
Your pix are merely shots of your reflection in shiny car parts. They convey nothing to the viewer about who/what you are. The best portraits let the viewer into the soul of the subject. For example, the portrait of Winston Churchill by Joseuf Karsch (do a Google). This lets you know that you don't want to screw with this guy.
Rarely is a self portrait sucessful....
This is my very first attempt circa 1972

Hello CarbonTerry,

Thanks for clearing things up. I have thought that this might be what you meant but I wasn't sure. Actually, I didn't meant to do a formal self portrait, I simply chose that title (innacurate, I admit) to refer to the fact that I was part of the picture.

I suppose that real self portraits must be very hard to do well. I can't figure out how I would make one work if I was to try it.

best regards

Seb

[readingr]

Hi Seb,

The bigger question is would we want to see your slef portrait?? Teee Heee!

Now for comments on the photo I do like the concept and I personally prefer the less zoomed picture as it clearly defines the mirror of the car. The bottom one of the two the trim in the bottom third of the mirror sorts of cuts off the bottom part.

How do your mirrors stay so clean and scratch free? Perhaps its the english and welsh narrow roads that I drive down.

[Seb]

Hello Rogers

The bigger question is would we want to see your slef portrait?? Teee Heee!

You might be pleasantly surprise you know lol!!

Now for comments on the photo I do like the concept and I personally prefer the less zoomed picture as it clearly defines the mirror of the car. The bottom one of the two the trim in the bottom third of the mirror sorts of cuts off the bottom part.

This is my personal favorite of the three too.

How do your mirrors stay so clean and scratch free? Perhaps its the english and welsh narrow roads that I drive down.

I can't speak about english road (never went there although I necessarily will sooner or later) but this was shot using a brand new car at a dealership.

regards

Seb

[readingr]

Ahh! a cheat! (New car)

So when can we expect the real thing?

by the way what does lol stand for?

[CarbonTerry]

It's a wonderful thing that so many folks can have so many different perceptions and all of them be correct. I was trying to push Seb and others past the norm of their photo craft. If you never go past the limits of your "comfort zone" you will never improve.
Seb....why don't you take the challenge and do a meaningful "self portrait"?

[Seb]

It's a wonderful thing that so many folks can have so many different perceptions and all of them be correct. I was trying to push Seb and others past the norm of their photo craft. If you never go past the limits of your "comfort zone" you will never improve.

Indeed, I see your point.

Seb....why don't you take the challenge and do a meaningful "self portrait"?

To tell you the thruth, I don't really have any interest in portraits (or self portraits for that matter) but it can't hurt to try. All that being said, I'd like to know what you think about the photograph submitted here.

regards

Seb

[CarbonTerry]

It is really a challenge to do a great job in an area that has no interest to you. That's when you will learn something that will stay with you.
I would choose the wide version over the close ups. Its result is to make you a part of the composition that the viewer has to find. In other words you are not hitting them over the head with the technique. You are able to have an overall composition that is more pleasing than "Look at me in the reflection of this thing."
That said, it also depends on what you set out to do.

[Seb]

It is really a challenge to do a great job in an area that has no interest to you. That's when you will learn something that will stay with you.
I would choose the wide version over the close ups. Its result is to make you a part of the composition that the viewer has to find. In other words you are not hitting them over the head with the technique. You are able to have an overall composition that is more pleasing than "Look at me in the reflection of this thing."
That said, it also depends on what you set out to do.

I really appreciate your imput and I will attempt few self portrait later on (I have few concepts in mind but it imply shooting outdoor so I'll wait that our cold canadian winter is over to go for it.

Few things though:
1) as a non portraitist, it seems to me that crafting a succesful close up must be much harder than a "wide version" essentially because I see lesser place for creativity other than working with the lighting (of course, good lighting may be quite hard to get/create but it seems to me that there is not so much room for composition)

2) Overlooking the fact that I have titled this tread "Some sort of self portrait", I would really appreciate to have your opinion on the shots posted here. I mean, I get the feeling that you really don't like these (which is perfectly fine with me, you don't have to like them) but I would like to understand your opinion. It's part of the lurning curve.

regards

Seb

[Seb]

Ahh! a cheat! (New car)

So when can we expect the real thing?

by the way what does lol stand for?

lol: laugh out loud...

As for a serious self-portrait, we will see...

Seb

[Aaron]

And to sum it all up -- some things we just do for fun