boardwalk & reed

[SmartWombat]

But which one would you choose ...
The shot as I approached it, or one from vertically above it?

[n8]

first one. much more appealing.

[SmartWombat]

Thanks for the comment n8
Sometimes the forum displays them in different order.
For me the overhead shot (no perspective) is the first one.
Same for you?

[PhilF]

1st one... tones and textures are more pronounced and the shadows are nicely framed.

[OldClicker]

For me it's the first one (closer one). More color and texture. - Terry

[LeeIs]

Hey Paul, I go with the 1st one. The tonality, shadows and composition are great. I wish you had removed one of the branches off the 'reed'. I don't know what those things are called.

[gahspidy]

Second one for me. . .sharper and greater tonal range. Not as contrasty and so it does not immediately catch attention as the other, but after comparing i find I like the sharpness and tonal range of the second and the wow factor of the first wears off quickly.