Moving Photo Critique to the New Gallery

[Photo-John]

I've been planning on moving the Photo Critique forum to the new gallery. It has ratings, good message board capabilities, it links to the user profiles, and I think the thumbnails will increase views and responses. But I don't want to just pull the rug out from under the people who use this forum all the time. It's your forum. So what does everyone think about moving the Photo Critique forum to the new gallery system? Pros, cons? Should we have both? I really want to know what you think.

Thanks for your feedback!

[Sebastian]

I'm all for it. I also hate the guesswork behind clicking and finding something you didn't expect. Makes me not want to even look.

[dbutler]

I know I don't post here much but sometimes it feels like it's hunt-and-peck. I try not to critique photos that aren't my bag simply because I think I may judge more harshly because I don't like the topic than I would if it had been something I enjoyed (no offense guys, but MTB just is not my thing). But having to open each and everyone to see what's behind the subject (not all subjects reveal the content) gets tiring sometimes.

But with the new gallery, I love that not only can you see the pics right off the bat, but that you can go to a very specific category. So, put me down as the lone voice (so far) preferring the new gallery

D

[natatbeach]

More efficient and easier to use! I'm all for it...i don't post or critique as much cause it's a bear to try and open scroll read and respond...too much work too little time...it's a fab idea and I really find the new gallery more visually appealing.

[Asylum Steve]

John,

Like the others, I think it's all upside to make the move...

I've been planning on moving the Photo Critique forum to the new gallery. It has ratings, good message board capabilities, it links to the user profiles, and I think the thumbnails will increase views and responses. But I don't want to just pull the rug out from under the people who use this forum all the time. It's your forum. So what does everyone think about moving the Photo Critique forum to the new gallery system? Pros, cons? Should we have both? I really want to know what you think.

Thanks for your feedback!

[Peter_AUS]

Move it, Move It Now, Go On, Make my Day.

[kkraczek]

Great idea.... BTW, did you remove the quick rate feature permanently?

[Photo-John]

Yes, I removed the Quick Rate feature. It seemed to be confusing people, including me. Plus, I'd like people to post reasons/critiques for their ratings. I can put it back up, if people want. Let me know what you think.

[kkraczek]

Yes, I removed the Quick Rate feature. It seemed to be confusing people, including me. Plus, I'd like people to post reasons/critiques for their ratings. I can put it back up, if people want. Let me know what you think.

It's fine with me... I just noticed that some of my ratings had disappeared. I agree that ratings should also include explanations. Thanks!

[Sebastian]

PJ, quick ratings are bad. People need to be held accountable for what they say, being anonymous will ony make it easier to knock people down for stupid reasons like getting back at them. If your name is out there to see, you'll be more likely to be fair since everyone will know who posted that rating.

[Liz]

I think moving Critique is a great idea. I have one question.....is it going to be merged with the new gallery? In other words, for instance if it were set up now, would the gallery format the way it is be the place to critique?

Would the gallery as it is now change in any way?

Quick Rate feature. I think leaving it off is the way to go for 2 reasons. Yes, it is confusing IMO; then it takes too much time to get back to make a comment. The other reason is that IMO it is good that people take the responsibility of their rating. This prevents any trolls from rating for other reasons.

Liz

Yes, I removed the Quick Rate feature. It seemed to be confusing people, including me. Plus, I'd like people to post reasons/critiques for their ratings. I can put it back up, if people want. Let me know what you think.

[Photo-John]

would the gallery format the way it is be the place to critique?

Good question, Liz. The gallery would stay exactly as it is. I'd just add a new category called, Photo Critique.

[Chunk]

I've been planning on moving the Photo Critique forum to the new gallery. It has ratings, good message board capabilities, it links to the user profiles, and I think the thumbnails will increase views and responses. But I don't want to just pull the rug out from under the people who use this forum all the time. It's your forum. So what does everyone think about moving the Photo Critique forum to the new gallery system? Pros, cons? Should we have both? I really want to know what you think.

Thanks for your feedback!

...as long as everyone is acceptable to having their photos critiqued as well as praised. What makes the Critique Forum work is that acceptence.

A couple thoughts on the New Gallery.

You ought to comeup with a better name for it before "New Gallery" becames too entrenched. A couple years from now it won't sound right.

While there are already a LOT of categories for photos there, I wish there was an "Abstract" category as well.

[Liz]

just to clarify. If PC is separate (sort of) then people could post images in the gallery that they don't necessary want critiqued, and in the Critique section if they want a critique? And would there still be a "comment" and rating option in the gallery? Or am I not seeing it correctly?

Thanks for your patience. Especially thank you for working so hard so we can enjoy PR even more. It doesn't go unnoticed!

Liz

Good question, Liz. The gallery would stay exactly as it is. I'd just add a new category called, Photo Critique.

[Peter_AUS]

Personally myself, it either remains the way it is at present, in a thread view like this, or moves to the new look totally with this particular forum gone. You can't have both. The Viewfinder forum is a sort of psuedo Critique forum in a way.

[racingpinarello]

Having a photo critique forum is great...a perfect ideal and much easier to make comments on the photograph when you can see the thumbnail photo.

Plus, having accountability of who is posting what is very important.

This board get's better and better.

Loren

[mtbbrian]

I like! I like!
Brian
;-)