which one is better?

[k_thornburg]

Which edit do you like best?

[SmartWombat]

I would like a 4th crop
Take the 3rd image, crop at the waterline at the top, and from the right to remove the part of the path that sticks out.
Leave in the reflection of the other light.

Do you want me to make the edit and post what I mean?

[k_thornburg]

no thank you, i'll see if I can do it. i'm new to photoshop, so I need to learn to do it! Thank you for the suggestion!

[k_thornburg]

like this?

[SmartWombat]

Yes, that's what I had in mind.
Perhaps with a little more on the right.
I was holding a ruler up to the screen and guessing how far it needed to crop.
I think it could do with a bit more blue on the right.

Hey, what is this, critique forum ?