Ah yes...one more example which proves my colleague's saying: "photography is a bunch of subjective crap!"
Please don't take this wrong...take it as tongue-in-cheek humor we photographers face when we show our work to others. Show a photograph to an art director or editor one day and maybe they don't like it. Maybe it's one of my lifestyles shots of a couple and the editor is viewing it after having a rough morning with their spouse. Show it to them on another day and they love it. Go figure.
Alison, I think it's a wonderful photograph. I agree Hodgy about rotating the subject to change the light direction. However, I like the way the flat, broad light works - it gives it a high-key fashion look. And - to me - it's her expression that makes the image work.
From somewhere on Colorado's Continental Divide...
Matt Lit
www.LITfoto.com