Night Carousel

[arne saknussen]

I think I know at least one major flaw with this photo. I am curious to see if you agree. Please feel free to edit.

[Grandpaw]

Could it be one of these, Jeff

#1 not sharp
#2 horses going away from camera
#3 cropping
#4 lighting
#5 too busy

or maybe the lack of a subject

[Don Schaeffer]

very dull photo--no color or clear definition.

[Ridgetop]

I don't want to make the poster cry anymore than Grandpa and Don already have.

So, here's a good point: The lighting on the white horse is nice.

[arne saknussen]

Thanks Ridge, I can take it. I'm just wondering who Jeff is.

[Grandpaw]

Sorry about my answer. You did put it in the critique forum and ask if we could see a flaw. I didn't answer you to be mean or anything, I took your post as a challenge to see what we could see. Sorry if I gave too long an answer, Jeff I apologize :blush2:

[arne saknussen]

Please, please, please, no offense whatsoever. I put it out there, I expect honesty. And I agree with you for the most part and understand the other parts.


But who's Jeff?

[Greg McCary]

I agree with the others and yes if you can take the critiques and run with them you will certainly improve your skills a bunch. Not much gets by the sharp eyes here.