The Great Challenge..

[Ronnoco]

This has more to do with Brian's personal opinion and taste rather than any challenge remotely related to the quality of an image.

Get real! In professional competitions, no one is capable of comparing a black and white to a colour photo, or even a great portrait to a great action shot...:idea: :idea: :idea: That is why they have categories to restrict critique to like subjects and formats.
Apples are not compared to oranges in challenges with any credibility.

Then there is judging. Critiquing in any challenge or competition is based on a published set of criteria for the purpose of fairness and greater objectivity. The concept of trusting one judge with personal taste as his criteria is totally laughable.

Ronnoco

[yogestee]

You are taking things a tad too serious Ronnoco..There have been many great images both colour and mono posted in this forum..What my prime objective is is to see them in the same thread side by side..

Jurgen

[EastCoastHucker]

That was a great idea Jurgen...:thumbsup:

To bad is to late for me...

[ladybugamanda]

I think the thread should stay alive until the end of the month so the busy people have time to sort through their photos and post - once they find the thread! (-:

[readingr]

Okay,

Why not allow all the viewers to vote for the pictures so that you get a broadspectrum of influences selecting the best image. Can this be done on this forum?

Roger

[Alison]

I have so many.

[EastCoastHucker]

Great.. I'll give it a try with my A$$ Detector picture...
Hope my wife don't check this site or I'll be in trouble..;)
I don't remember the set up of the camera because I had a split second to get everything in the right "position", the camera was a Olympus C-7070

[Greg McCary]

Maybe instead of posting our own favorite picture we should post our favorites of other peoples stuff...
Greg

[Alison]

That made me laugh ECH!!! Funny pic.

Great idea Greg! But what you doin' with other people's stuff ;) (only kiddin)

Jurgen - Can we post more than one? :thumbsup:

[Frog]

The original post said to use photos that have already been posted.
Is that how its going?

[yogestee]

The original post said to use photos that have already been posted.
Is that how its going?

I certainly hope so..Ok,,,how about we extend the deadline until 1st January '07??

Jurgen

[Ronnoco]

Great.. I'll give it a try with my A$$ Detector picture...
Hope my wife don't check this site or I'll be in trouble..;)
I don't remember the set up of the camera because I had a split second to get everything in the right "position", the camera was a Olympus C-7070

Well, I would certainly give it, top prize in humour and unique visual impact.

Ronnoco

[Alison]

I certainly hope so..Ok,,,how about we extend the deadline until 1st January '07??

Jurgen

That's a long time. This will probably need to be a sticky then.

Also, are we allowed to post more than one Jurgen?

[yogestee]

Also, are we allowed to post more than one Jurgen?

Alison,,how about we stick to just one per person...That will stop posters flooding this thread with images..

Jurgen

[Greg McCary]

Maybe we could post one picture and then list the others if any, we liked. I have about three that I would mention in my post, but one clear favorite.

[MrParts]

Have fun with this ... I'm outta here.

[MrParts]

Could someone go ahead and delete my photo and it's settings?

[Alison]

Is anything happening with this thread?