Hey John,

I really think that the Camera Test Forum is a great asset. I found the test samples to be very helpful.

I am looking forward to seeing more cameras. When I get the MarkII I will bring it by your "lab".

Loren

Thanks for the feedback, Loren. I've been waiting for someone to comment. I want to keep the tests relatively simple. But if there are things people would like to see added, please let me know. I know I need to add a "Discuss" link so people can ask questions or add their thoughts.

The Pentax test is almost ready to go. I decided I wanted to reshoot the studio images so that set it back a bit. I also have the Olympus 5060 and there's an HP camera sitting next to me just waiting for me to have time to play with it. And I'm on the list for lost more. I think Uwe might share some of what he gets with me, too.

If anyone else has anything to say, please share. I really want to know what you think.

Thanks-

I like it too, seeing how the first camera tested is my camera! :)

PJ,

I think I'll have to go against the grain here. I question the need to do this when there are sites out there that already are well established at this, and do a much more thorough job.

I guess I just wonder if it's worthwhile to be using resources to compete against such heavyweights as Phil Askey.

BUT, I do see the value in having everything on one site.

Since this is the feedback forum I thought I'd share my thoughts on the matter. :)

Hi John,


I think it's great that you've added a camera test page to the site. Even though there may be more comprehensive and "scientific" tests out there, people are always looking for resources that will help them make choices about equipment. .... or validate their purchases.


Ivan

My intention is not to copy or compete with other professional review sites. My real goal is to supply something different. That something different is the controlled studio testing. I'm not aware of anyone else doing anything as controlled and objective as the studio shots I've done. And since I have the cameras, I might as well use them and share a bit my impressions and the photos that result. But I don't want to get into the business of teling people what they should and shouldn't buy. I'll leave that up to the community and the user reviews here.

Going to Sea Otter this year?

Sebastian-
I don't feel the need to compete with Phil Askey. I don't want to do what he does. But I did identify one thing that was missing on the Internet. That was very controlled and objective studio tests. That's what this is really about. The rest of the "test" is just a better way for me to organize the kind of stuff I would normally just post in the other forums.

Sebastian-
I don't feel the need to compete with Phil Askey. I don't want to do what he does. But I did identify one thing that was missing on the Internet. That was very controlled and objective studio tests. That's what this is really about. The rest of the "test" is just a better way for me to organize the kind of stuff I would normally just post in the other forums.

I understand, makes more sense now.

But if people did find they appreciated what I'm doing more than some of the other sites, I wouldn't complain :cool:

But if people did find they appreciated what I'm doing more than some of the other sites, I wouldn't complain :cool:

I don't buy it.

I know for a fact that you desire no rewards for this site, you do it strictly out of the goodness of your heart and never ask for anything in return.

All you buddhists are the same, with your long hair and your tatoos and your crazy hippie thoughts....

Your best post ever.

My intention is not to copy or compete with other professional review sites. My real goal is to supply something different. That something different is the controlled studio testing. I'm not aware of anyone else doing anything as controlled and objective as the studio shots I've done. And since I have the cameras, I might as well use them and share a bit my impressions and the photos that result. But I don't want to get into the business of teling people what they should and shouldn't buy. I'll leave that up to the community and the user reviews here.

Going to Sea Otter this year?


I didn't know that was still going on? I thought it was going to be held at Infineon? i'm probably not going this year. Been really, really busy. Especially on the weekends. Are you going?


Ivan