Tree in the Field

[Greg McCary]

Should I clone the moon? I tried to re size it but it didn't look right...But this is as is.

[icicle]

I would try cloning it out or cropping it out.
Looks nice.

[PrevailingConditions]

I think I'd leave the moon, but crop off some on the right side so that the tree wasn't so centered. Perhaps try a 4x3 or square aspect ratio? Otherwise, I like it.

PC

[Frog]

I'm going to agree with the right side crop. The moon, I would leave.
Something about this photo makes me keep looking at it.

Is it early morning or evening? The light makes me believe morning.
What is the crop in the field?

[Greg McCary]

Thanks all. Here is the tree cropped a little further right. Frog I think it is soy bean, not sure. Yes very early.

[hminx]

The edit looks better, perhaps some sort of halo effect around the moon may be what you are after.

[MNRyan]

I really like to edited version. I think the halo idea would look good or maybe adding a larger moon in, but that might also take away form it too.

[Greg McCary]

Thanks Ryan, Pete the halo is an interesting idea I will see what it takes to PS one.

[jetrim]

Love the crop, and think the halo might be just the thing. Try a large soft brush on a new layer and then a slightly smaller eraser brush with the same softness to remove the center.

[gahspidy]

Love the mood of this pic, Greg. The crop looks better. I think the moon is fine as it is and def should not remove it, but if you play with adding a halo and get it right it could add.
wouldn't go too far with it though. i like this one alot.

[Don Schaeffer]

Very special photo. I don't see why the cropped version is better. The original looked stable and settled like the mood of the photo.

[Greg McCary]

Thanks for the tip Jetrim I will see what I can do and try not to over do it. Thanks Gary, Thanks Don.