Quote Originally Posted by mtbbrian
Here there is a fine line we have to walk between, there are a lot of new people that need that "false praise" at first, but someone like you and me need no no nonesense comments.
Brian
I give a lot of people praise, I think, but I don't think any of it has been false. That said, I do think there was an upswing in critiqueless 'that's nice' kind of replies a while back after there was a complaint about not getting enough responses.

One can mention what one likes about a shot (praise) as well as suggesting improvements. I think suggesting alternatives is a better way of doing things than posting 'that's wrong' or 'it doesn't follow the rules' comments.