Please post no more than five images a day and respond to as many images as you post. Critics, please be constructive, specific, and nice! Moderated by gahspidy and mtbbrian.
By posting on the Photo Critique forum you agree to post only your own photos, be respectful, and give back as much as you receive. This is a moderated forum and anything abusive or
off-topic will be removed.
I think as photographers we want to capture images that set us apart from "just some guy with a camera." Part of the process is to think about what is in and isn't in the frame of our images.
Notice how the legs are chopped off the 2 men on the far right of the frame? Notice how the sky fills at least 40% of the frame? What in this image is interesting and says "ball game"? All that sky doesn't fill a special need but having more people (or bigger people) would likely make this a stronger image.
I think you should have pointed the camera lower, moved a step or 2 closer to the subjects and perhaps reduce the contrast just a bit. That way the details would be clearer, the essence of the ball park experience would be stronger and there would be less empty space in the frame.
MB1, you're absolutely right. This is a nice snapshot taken by a tourist. It really isn't a photograph of anything in particular and doesn't convey any emotion at all. I also get a feeling of being off-balance - the tilted roadsign doesn't help.
There are no rules for good photographs, there are only good photographs. - Ansel Adams
hi, every time i try and take a photo like the one you have posted the blue sky comes out white.. doyou use a filter to give the sky its natural colour? ( bit of a noobie question i know)
MB1, you're absolutely right. This is a nice snapshot taken by a tourist. It really isn't a photograph of anything in particular and doesn't convey any emotion at all. I also get a feeling of being off-balance - the tilted roadsign doesn't help.
well, I guess I wouldn't consider myself a tourist, considering I live 1/2 mile down the block, and as for the emotion, I'm sure anyone who has ever been to Wrigley on opening week would disagree....The two men in the foreground definitely take away from the pic....or maybe I should have waited another 20 minutes until the who road was blocked off with excited fans....couldn't do much about the tilted signs, because if I made them straight, I would have tilted the ballpark. If anything, I think the sign helps draw the eye to the central image...the Wrigley Field facade. I supposed I could have shot less sky, but atleast it was a beautiful day ..... I feel it adds to the sublime aspect of the ballpark.
"The force of art lies in its immediate influence on human psychology and in its active contagiousness."
well, I guess I wouldn't consider myself a tourist, considering I live 1/2 mile down the block, and as for the emotion, I'm sure anyone who has ever been to Wrigley on opening week would disagree....The two men in the foreground definitely take away from the pic....or maybe I should have waited another 20 minutes until the who road was blocked off with excited fans....couldn't do much about the tilted signs, because if I made them straight, I would have tilted the ballpark. If anything, I think the sign helps draw the eye to the central image...the Wrigley Field facade. I supposed I could have shot less sky, but atleast it was a beautiful day ..... I feel it adds to the sublime aspect of the ballpark.
I think the important thing to remember is that none of us were there. None of us could feel the excitement as yet another Cubs season opens with potential only to be doused by mid-July. (I'm a Mariners fan, I can say that... )
Seriously, your job as the photog is to make us feel what you felt. It's a tough assignment. MB gave some great pointers and while you're free to disregard them, you may want to reconsider the comments of an unbiased observer.
I agree with MB, but also feel a couple of big steps left and shooting up the road and use it to draw the viewers eyes into the shot would work. Also try and not have things hanging out of the frame. The truck on the left and light pole on the right. Those should be cloned.
I am like Barney Fife, I have a gun but Andy makes me keep the bullet in my pocket..
I have enjoyed looking at the scene in your photo, but to bring this up to a higher level I agree with MB1's points. I think you have tried to include too much in the scene, where usually "less is more" holds true more often than not. Also, the hard lighting of mid day made this difficult for you to capture without all that contrast.. It helps usually to try and think about isolating the parts of a given scene that really contain what you want to show, and leave the extraneous stuff out.
If you want to capture the excitement of the day, you'll either need to get in close on a couple of rabid fans or maybe go to one of the neighboring rooftops and take a broader shot when the surrounding streets are packed with people.
"Photography as a fad is well-nigh on its last legs, thanks principally to the bicycle craze."
-- Alfred Stieglitz The American Annual of Photography, 1897 L.A. Landscapes
thanks, I got the shot last sunday late after the Astros game, right in front of the cubby bear. There were still some people out chanting "***edome!" walking down the street haha