Which is better?

[Christian Simpson]

I relly like this picture, but i cant decide which one i like more...any input?

[mondo1090]

i like the second one better, but i think id like it more if it was all B/W

[freygr]

I don't like either (I don't like the crop a personal preference), but the second I have to agree with mondo1090 it should be all B&W and would look better with a little less contrast as the milk pops too much.

[jbaldocchi]

The first image is great! You've captured the moment. The second one is a little sci-fi for me. I like color used in B&W but this looks a bit gimmicky.

Just my opinion,

Jim B.

[Chunk]

The first is better and could be even better than it is with a warmer cast.

[Christian Simpson]

thanks a lot guys, i'll keep these thoughts in mind...