Thanks for the feedback. I'll give that crop a try and see what it looks like.

One of the things I liked about the shot though was that it included a home and signs of life, like the car and the outdoor light. So many sunset shots are just of the sunset taken out of context. To me, having the home in the shot makes it a part of every day life and somehow that makes me more thankful for a beautiful sunset. "I'm just sitting here at home, with my family, on a typical Tuesday night, but right outside my window is nature in all her glory." It connects the sunset to man as opposed to some disconnected event. Or perhaps I'm just talking a lot of BS.

I also like how the reflection adds to the shot, but perhaps that makes it too busy.

I spent a week last month on vacation, staying at the house to the left of this one (it's behind the trees so you can't see it). It was right on the water, facing west so every night we had a gorgeous sunset, one more beautiful than the next. It was the least stressed out I've been in years!