Alamo Glass

[photophorous]

Crop or no crop?

Thanks!
Paul

[drg]

I like the uncropped one better between these two. Better context.

[zrfraser]

I like the cropped one better, but I am fan of tight crops. I like the pic though and photographing graffiti is one of my favorite subjects.

[photophorous]

Thanks for the opinions! I plan to print this one tonight.

Anyone want to break the tie? Or, should I just save my paper?

Thanks,
Paul

[srobb]

I would have to say crop. At least enough to take out what little sky is there. It adds nothing to it for me.

[readingr]

Paul,

I find there are too many distractions which are competing for my attention in both pictures.

I would consider a more sever crop from the edge of the building to the edge of the window and attempt to clone out the cable going across the building.

Roger

[SmartWombat]

Crop or no crop?

Crop even more ?
I don't think you/ve gone far enough ...

[photophorous]

Okay, for the more-crop fans, how about these?

When I said I was going to print this tonight, I meant in a dark room, so I won't be cloning out that cable...unfortunately. If that is even possible in the dark room, I don't have the skills for it.

Thanks again!

Paul

[RebelXT-WH2CYK]

i think a crop like this will work best, just my opinion

[zrfraser]

I like this crop mostly, but I feel like the graffitti needs A little more room. It looks squashed on that side. I focus more on the doorway, when I want to look at the graffitti.