4th in PA

[Juanjo Viagran]

Hi,
a little late I know... ;)
C&C welcome.

[Charles Hess]

Of the 3, I like the third one simply because a little detail is seen in the house and the lawn. I'm not sure what the other stuff is on the ground...I assume it's more fireworks items, but if you wanted to make this a serious, good for framing, photo I would have removed all of that clutter before shooting.

[Frog]

That second one is kind of interesting in b/w. Looks like an old photograph.
I agree that the third is the best and I don't mind the clutter, thinking it adds perspective and/or ambveance,(hate that word).

[Herriot]

Of the 3 the third wins my vote for the same reason already mentioned by Charles, the objects on the ground help the overall composition IMO

[GB1]

Ha ! Fun shots. I also think the 3rd is the most successful due to its composition , color and contrast. I do like the first one too, bottle rockets are FUN !!

The second one almost pushed me out of my chair, it's like you are in a war zone and a bomb just went off in front of you .. maybe the last thing you see (yikes)! Fade into black......

G