4 seasons in 1 image

[Gohan]

Please comment if you understood what is shown and if it is interesting

[shesells]

Yes, I do understand and Yes, it's totally interesting and Wow! What a cool shot. Well executed and boy do you have patience.
Kit

[Chunk]

Please comment if you understood what is shown and if it is interesting

I like it. I like the subject as well. The two trees remind of one of those old couples who seem like a single entity. It'll look so unbalance should one get blown down. Nice work.

[PuckJunkey]

A very cool approach to a popular landscape concept... I like it a lot. I will say the image on the left is a bit hazy / flat in terms of the exposure. A little highlight and shadow might help there since the shot opposite (at right) is so vivid and colorful. Winter looks good, spring maybe could use a bit more saturation.

[gahspidy]

Yes, I like this too, interesting concept. and I agree with Shesells about your patience. . . to stand in the same spot for a year to get the job done ;)

[Gohan]

Thank you all very much for interesting comments. I didn't stand there for a whole year At first I even didn't plan about such composition, but in spring I saw that I have two similar photos taken in autumn and winter, so decided to finish the job.
The quality isn't so good because taking picture in autumn I was novice in photography (have just bought the camera) and as you see I have made big jump forward (summer picture).
I agree that the tree is also interesting. It is absolutely symmetric!

Well, wait for a year and you will see another interesting composition

P.S. Comments are still welcome

[shesells]

Yes, I like this too, interesting concept. and I agree with Shesells about your patience. . . to stand in the same spot for a year to get the job done ;)

LOL!!..........

[another view]

This is a good project to work on, and I've never seen it done this way. Very cool! Couple of things, I'd like to see the winter shot adjusted just a little bit so that the horizon line is straight all the way across.

And also, the light is pretty flat on these shots - try going out early or late in the day and you'll find better light. It might take a couple of trips to get a really good shot of each season but the results are worth it.

[gmen]

The concept is excellent and it makes for a good set of images.

Am I seeing things or is the left hand strip narrower than the others? Is that intentional?

[Chunk]

Thank you all very much for interesting comments. I didn't stand there for a whole year At first I even didn't plan about such composition, but in spring I saw that I have two similar photos taken in autumn and winter, so decided to finish the job.
The quality isn't so good because taking picture in autumn I was novice in photography (have just bought the camera) and as you see I have made big jump forward (summer picture).
I agree that the tree is also interesting. It is absolutely symmetric!

Well, wait for a year and you will see another interesting composition

P.S. Comments are still welcome

Get some nice autumn foliage to replace the first slice. You CAN see the improvement you made, I can't wait for next year's version.

[Gohan]

I am thankful all of you for interesting ideas and critique. It was vey useful.

Now I shall try to explain your queries. The left strip is narrower and the horizont line of winter doesn't fit the others because I was shooting the tree from different positions and I had to correct the dissonance. Unfortunately, this is the best I could do.

I say, wait for another year and you'll see a perfect project! ;)
But maybe you will soon attain an improved version with the first slice replacement.

Be attentive and keep on commenting!