I have been told over and over again that I would like this triology. So finally last Friday I rented all three, turned down the lights and watched one each night with the Return of the King coming last night.
I have to say that I enjoyed the series, though my expectations were high due to all the buzz. I have not read the books, btw. It was not a "great" series by any means, though it definitely was impactful and has stuck with me in my thoughts and mental images since.
I think the first one was the best of the three. I think the director got a little carried away with the battle scenes. We've all already seen "Braveheart." The scenes of two lines of soldiers clashing has worn thin. The magic stuff was pretty cool though.
It was a different kind of story in that the main character, Frodo, really didn't undergo a personal journey like most movie protagonists (if he qualified for that) do. It was more like, just stay alive Frodo! I guess the real personal journey was taken my Aragorn. Though his internal struggle was not apparent.
One thing I have to commend the director for is the casting. Couldn't get any better if you ask me. Particular standouts for me were: Sean Astin as Sam (Rudy! Rudy!), Orlando Bloom was beautiful as the Elf, Ian McClelan was perfect as the wizard, and Viggor Mortenson nearly stole the show as Aragorn. Really strong acting all around!
Other than that, the script was a little bumpy at times, though in watching the extra features it apparently was quite the task taking TLOTR from book form to the big screen. That, and too many battle scenes for me are my biggest complaints.
So, any fans? I know it's been a few years, and I have missed all the buzz Curious about others' takes on the book and the movie triology.
Rick