Brian,

This is not about Digital vs. whatever at all, the second image is better because of framing, lighting and contrast, stuff that can be done with any medium. Two different settings, two different looks, and two different proceses, no way to compare them whatsoever.

Sure, there is a certain quality to the work that can not be reproduced by other processes, but to say that it's better than those is missing the point, IMO.

GJphoto,

Welcome. I think the process that you use and the way it forces you to approach and view your subjects will let you provide a very unique viewpoint on this site. Looking forward to seeing and reading more form you.

Take care guys!