November 1

[Don Schaeffer]

Superimposed a highly sharpened layer on the original photo

[MB1]

There is a little bit too much contrast here for me and I would crop some off the top and either the right or left (whatever it is that looks like an orange plastic bag in the upper right has to go).

Now that I think about it a little more what I like about this image is the pumpkin and the wall it is resting on. You might try cropping everything but that and see what you get. That might end my contrast issue with the image too.

[dbutler]

I can't believe I'm saying this but I also find it too contrasty. You have so much texture in this shot. From the pumpkin, to the snow, the stone in the foreground, the bricks, the tree and the wall in the far background. Lots going on, all good. I'd like to see it with less sharpening for comparison.