Black & White method...

In another thread someone mentioned that some ways of converting a digital color to black and white are better than others. Here are the four ways that I know of in Elements 6. Please comment on the differences, your preferences and why. - TF

EDIT: If you feel that you could better demonstrate with the original file and do your own conversion, I would be glad to send it to you. - TF

1- Desaturation
2- Remove Color
3- Grayscale
4- Convert to BW, Default Settings
5- Convert to BW, My Settings?????

-